Rail Manufacture

The steel used for the manufacture of rails is made by the open hearth or duplex process and should not have a wide variation in its chemical composition. There are essentially four stages of rail manufacturing.

(a) Steel manufacturing process using a basic oxygen/electric arc furnace, including argon rinsing and degassing

(b) Continuous casting of blooms

(c) Rail rolling process including controlled cooling

(d) Rail finishing including eddy current testing, ultrasonic testing, and finishing work

A typical flow chart for the manufacture of rails at the Bhilai steel plant in India is given in Fig. 6.6.

6.4.1 Rail Specifications (IRS-T-12-96)

These specifications apply to flat-bottom symmetrical rails. The quality of steel, manufacturing process, chemical composition, acceptance tests, qualifying criteria, and other technical conditions are given below.

Quality of steel The steel for rails should be of fully killed quality and should conform to the chemical composition and mechanical properties specified in Table 6.3.

Branding and stamping Rails should be hot branded on one side of the web showing relevant details. Each rail should be identified by hot stamping at least once every 4.0 m on the web and should be colour coded in order to distinguish the grade, class, length, and other special requirements.

Hot metal Liquid steel Clean liquid steel with H2

Process of rail manufacture at Bhilai steel plant, India Table 6.3 Desirable properties of steel for rails (a) Chemical composition
Fig. 6.6 Process of rail manufacture at Bhilai steel plant, India Table 6.3 Desirable properties of steel for rails (a) Chemical composition

Grade C

Mn Si S (max.)

P (max.) Al (max.) Liquid hydrogen

880 0.6-0.8

0.8-1.3 1.3-0.5 0.035*

0.035* 0.02 3.00

* The maximum value for finishing is 0.040.

(b) Mechanical properties

UTS

Elongation % on gauge

Running surface hardness

(MPa; min.)

length = 5.65/S* (min.)

880

10.0

Min. 260T

* S = cross-sectional area of piece in mm2. t Desirable values.

Rolling quality Each section of the rail should be accurately rolled to its respective template (prepared by the manufacturer and approved by the purchaser or inspecting agency) within permissible tolerance or variations.

Free from defects The rails should be free from all detrimental defects such as cracks of all kinds, flaws, piping, and lack of metal that have an unfavourable effect on the behaviour of rails in service.

Straightness The rail should be absolutely straight. Tolerances for end straightness are very stringent as indicated in Table 6.4.

Table 6.4 Tolerances for end straightness

Straightness

Tolerance

Class A rails

Class B rails

Horizontal

Vertical

Deviation of 0.5 mm measured as maximum ordinate from the chord of 2.0 m standard sraight edge

Deviation of 0.7 mm measured as maximum ordinate from the chord of 1.5 m standard straight edge

(a) Up sweep

Deviation of 0.4 mm measured as maximum ordinate from the chord of 2.0 m the standard straight edge

Deviation of 0.5 mm measured as maximum ordinate from the chord of 1.5 m standard straight edge

(b) Down sweep

-

-

Permissible Variations in Dimensions

The tolerances allowed in the various parameters of a rail section are given in Table 6.5. These tolerances are subject to the condition that the actual weight determined by weighing the rail piece falls 0.5% below and 1.5% above the calculated weight.

Table 6.5 Permissible variation in dimensions of rails

Item

Permissible variations in dimensions of rails

Overall height

+ 0.8 mm to -0.4 mm

Width of head

0.5 mm (width of head measured 14 mm below the rail top)

Width of flange

1.0 mm (for sections less than 60 kg/m)

+ 1.2 mm, -1.0 mm (for sections 60 kg/m and above)

Thickness of web

+ 1.0 mm to -0.5 mm (measured at the point of minimum thickness)

Vertical flange

1.2 mm (for flange width less than and equal to 150 mm)

The base of the rail should be true and flat, but a slight concavity not exceeding 0.40 mm is permissible.

Length of rails

+ 2.0 mm to -10 mm

(contd )

Item

Permissible variations in dimensions of rails

Fishing surfaces

The standard template for the rail fishing surface should not stand away from the contour of the web by more than 1.20 mm and the

clearance at the finishing surfaces should not exceed 0.18 mm at any point.

End squareness

The deviation from the square in both horizontal and vertical directions should not exceed 0.60 mm.

Straightness

The maximum permissible deviation should be 0.70 mm, measured as the maximum ordinate on a chord of 1.5 m. Wavy, kinky, and twisted rails should not be accepted.

End straightness

Rails are classified into A and B categories. The details are given in Table 6.4.

Fishbolt holes

Diameter of holes: 0.70 mm centring and positioning of holes vertically and 0.70 mm horizontally

Important tests for rails

The following tests are conducted to determine the serviceability of a rail section.

Falling weight or tup test A rail piece of 1.5 m (5 ft) is cut. The rail is supported between the bearers at a prescribed distance. A tup of specified weight (1000 kg for a 90 R rail) is dropped from a height of 7.2 m on the centre of the test piece. The specimen should withstand the blow without any fracture. One falling weight test is done for every cast of 100 metric t. The weight of the tup, distance between the centres of the bearings, and the weight of the drop for different rail sections is given in Table 6.6.

Table 6.6 Details of the tup test

Rail section

Wt of tup (kg)

Distance between centres of bearings (m)

Height of drop (m)

60 kg/m

1270

1.07

8.4

52 kg/m

1270

1.20

7.6

90 R

1000

1.10

7.2

75 R

1000

1.10

6.0

Tensile test A test piece is taken from the head of a rail section and subjected to the tensile test. The tensile strength of the rail should not be less than 72 kg/mm2, with a minimum elongation of 14% for medium manganese rails and 12% for carbon quality rails. This test is optional and is to be carried out when required by the inspecting official.

Hammer test The foot of the test rail piece is rigidly gripped in a vertical position and the head of the rail is struck with a 4.5 kg hammer. Sufficient number of blows are given till the web bends and the dimensional value of A given in Table 6.7 (Fig. 6.7) is achieved. No fracture should occur or a lap be disclosed, otherwise

the batch is rejected. This test is no longer required as per IRS/T- 18-88. The values of A for various rail sections are listed is Table 6.7.

Hammer test
Fig. 6.7 Hammer test

Table 6.7 Values of A for different rail sections

Rail section

52 kg/m

90 R

75 R

60 R

50 R

Dimension A in mm

157

144.5

130

117.7

108

Second Quality Rails

Rails that have been rejected either individually or by cast for having failed to fulfil the requirements of IRS specification no. T-12 with regard to chemical composition, or have failed due to defects in surface dimensions and length, may be accepted as second quality rails (T-18) for use in loops and sidings. These second quality rails should conform to the following specifications.

Chemical composition

The chemical composition of the rails should conform to the values given in Table 6.8.

Table 6.8 Required chemical composition for second quality rails*

Element % in carbon steel % in medium Revised % in medium

manganese steel manganese steel

Carbon

0.50-0.70

0.40-0.60

0.40-0.65

Manganese

0.60-0.95

0.90-1.45

0.85-1.45

Sulphur

0.06 max.

0.06 max.

0.06 max.

Phosphorus

0.06 max.

0.06 max.

0.06 max.

Silicon

0.03-0.30

0.03-0.30

0.03-0.30

* As per the revised specifications, the percentage of C + Mn should in no case be less than 1.3%. In case carbon exceeds 0.6%, then C + Mn should not exceed 2%.

Surface defects

The following maximum dimensions of the rail surface are considered as minor defects. Rails with these defects are acceptable.

Table of the rail: 0.80 mm

Side of head of the rail: 1.60 mm

Bottom and side of the rail: 1.60 mm

Permissible variations in dimensions

Overall height of the rail: + 1.60 mm, -0.80 mm Width of head: + 1.20 mm Thickness of web: + 1.60 mm, -0.60 mm Length of rail: 25 mm

Difference in theoretical and actual weight: 1%

Such rails are identified by chamfering a 6-mm-diameter hole at either end, along the centre of the rail and in the middle of the web. These rails are to be used only on loop lines/sidings with a speed restriction of 50 kmph. These rails are painted orange on both sides of the web for a length of 1 m from each end for easy identification.

Third Quality Rails

These are rails that do not conform to the standards set for first or second quality rails but are still fit for use on the railway track. For safety considerations, these are used in industrial sidings where speeds are restricted to 30 kmph for BG and 25 kmph for MG.

Such rails are identified by chamfering a 12-mm-diameter hole at either end, along the centre of the rail and in the middle of the web. A 18 mm marking 'I.U.' is stamped on both end faces of the rail. Third quality rails are painted white on the end face on both sides of the flange for a length of 500 mm from each end for identification.

Third quality rails are manufactured using rejected heats/rails which do not conform to IRS T-12 or T-18 standards with regard to chemical composition, surface defects, dimensions, and straightness.

6.4.4 90 UTS Rails

Indian Railways has mostly been using medium manganese rails with an ultimate tensile strength (UTS) of 72 kg/mm2 manufactured by the Bhilai steel plant. The service life of 52 kg (72 UTS) rails is only about 350 GMT. On a section with an annual traffic density of about 20 GMT, the renewal cycle is just about 17-18 years, which is rather short as compared to the service life of 50 years of a concrete sleeper. Moreover, such rails wear faster on curves and gradient sections.

In view of the above considerations, Indian Railways has been importing 52-kg and 90 R, 90 UTS rails for some time. These rails have the following main advantages.

1. The service life of 90 UTS rails is about 50% more than that of conventional medium manganese 72 UTS rails.

2. The total GMT that 72 and 90 UTS rails can carry during their primary service life is as follows:

52 kg (72 UTS): 350 GMT 52 kg (90 UTS): 525 GMT 60 kg (90 UTS): 900 GMT

3. 90 UTS rails are more resilient against wear and have a hardness of about 270 BHN (Brinell hardness number) as against that of 220 BHN of medium manganese rails with 72 UTS.

4. The allowable shear stress of 90 UTS rails is much higher, as can be seen from the comparative figures given below:

Rails Allowable shear stress

Medium manganese rails (72 UTS) 18.0 kg/mm2

Wear-resistant rails (90 UTS) 22.5 kg/mm2

Studies have shown that the maximum shear stress due to BOX N wagons could be of the order of 20.0 kg/mm2, which is in excess of the permissible shear stress for medium manganese 72 UTS rails. Therefore, for routes on which BOX N wagons are running, it is desirable to have 90 UTS rails.

End-hardened rails

These are rails with ends that are hardened by oil or water quenching. The wear and tear and end batter of such rails is considerably less.

Head-hardened rails

These are rails with heads that have been hardened by passing them through a thermal treatment plant. The head is hardened for a depth of about 12 mm from the surface. Head hardened rails have a longer service life that extends up to 2-3 times more compared to as ordinary medium manganese rails.

The chemical composition of head-hardened steel (grade 1080) is prescribed as given in Table 6.9.

Table 6.9 Chemical composition of head-hardened rail

Item

Carbon

Manganese

Silicon

Sulphur

Phosphorus

Limit of values

0.72-0.82

0.75-1.05

0.05-0.30

0.035 max.

0.035 max.

Requirements for an Ideal Rail Section | RAILWAY ENGINEERING - Contents | Rail Wear